A few days ago I spent about two days reading Christopher Paolini's
Eragon and
Elder, the first two books in the Inheritance trilogy. It was a decent read, but nothing to go nuts over. The story has all the familiar elements: elves and dwarves acting out their stereotypes, strong friendships that turn to betrayal, war, and the emergence of a hero from a nobody kid. It's very much a coming-of-age story, and seems so far to be a cross of the Lord of the Rings, Anne McCaffrey's Dragonriders of Pern and Harry Potter. It's overwritten in some areas and underwritten in others, but the story itself is a pretty good one.
I just wonder about the elves. They hood the boy so the other elves won't notice that he's human, but they do nothing about the dwarf, when dwarves haven't been seen in their realm for ages… seems to me that dwarves aren't exactly inconspicuous. And what about the horse? He told it to stay there and wait for him, then he leaves without it. Makes me wonder if it's still there…
It's the little things that bug me. It's a decent read, though. Out of 5, I'd give it a 3.5. Worth reading if you like that kind of thing, but probably not something I'd read again. The movie comes out next week, though, and I'm sure I'm going to go see it.
Labels: fantasy, science fiction